Joyeux noel is an exceptional film that tells the true story of the spontaneous 1914 christmas truce of world war i. The film does an exquisite job at bringing the characters to life, and at. Pope benedict xv, leader of the catholic church, was very much against the war and had already tried that very autumn to get the fighting governments to agree to an official christmas. It was nominated for an oscar for best foriegn language film. Joyeux noel starts with jonathan and william, two young brothers from scotland, eagerly enlisting in the great war. The film was advertised as based on a true story, but neither the marketing nor anything in the film claims it to be a historically accurate account of the events. Joyeux noel reminds us to soften our political barriers. A christmas truce forged by germans, french and scots. Officers and troops were punished for fraternizing with the enemy in wartime. In his podcast about the historical accuracy of films. If we are publishing it now, it is because the 1914 christmas truce has become something of a media celebrity 100 years after the event with its own website, and even an advert for sainsburys supermarkets taking the truce as a theme.
Joyeux noel, a glossy french antiwar movie with melted snowflakes in its eyes, tells the true story of an improvised christmas truce during the. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The year is 1914, and as world war i continues to rage across the european countryside, four individuals stuck on the front lines find themselves faced with the unthinkable in director christian carions academy awardnominated account of the truelife wartime event that would offer hope for peace in. Joyeux noel, french for merry christmas, is the story about a group of soldiers scots, french, and germans who laid down their arms and joined each other in peace during christmas, if only for a few days. But carion says that the detail is historically accurate. It was also the plot of the 2005 french film joyeux noel, which. Joyeux noel, a new film, directed by christian carion, is about the unofficial 1914 christmas truce in the trenches of the western front. One names the cat felix and the other nestor, and when the two meet in no mans land during thet ruce, a sweet argument ensues between the two men over whose cat it is and what is, in fact, its name. Does anybody know how accurate this impression is andor generally how accurate the movie was to what happened in real life. In december 1914, an unofficial christmas truce on the western front allows soldiers from opposing sides of the first world war to gain insight into each others way of life. The astonishing war story that a nation chose to forget. Joyeux noel brings out the human side of a war, the fear, the homesickness and the heartbreak, without being too gruesome.
It has some of the most uplifting and most powerful christmas scenes ever put on film, but there are a. On christmas eve on the western front spontaneous ceasefires broke out along parts of the front. In the film, he was nestor to the scottish and fritzi to the germans. Academy awardr, golden glober and bafta nominee for best foreign film, joyeux noel merry christmas tells the truelife story of the spontaneous christmas eve truce declared by scottish, french and german troops in the trenches of world war i. If you know the answer to this question, please register to join our limited beta program and start the. On christmas eve of 1914, a remarkable event took place in the trenches where the germans faced the british and the french. The cat existed, and, in real life, it was arrested by the french, convicted of. On december 17, 20 may 4, 2015 by chronic chronicler in drama, film, historical. That film, joyeux noel merry christmas, a panoramic portrait of soldiers from three countries who participated in one of these occasions, set boxoffice records in france last month for a subtitled film it is shot in french, german and english and is the countrys entry for the academy awards. It was written and directed by christian carion, and screened out of competition at the 2005 cannes film festival. Payne began by discussing the films historical accuracy. But its director, christian carion, claims the film is historically accurate.
However on christmas eve, numerous sections of the western front called an informal, and unauthorized, truce where the various frontline soldiers of the conflict peacefully met each other in no mans land to share a precious pause in. This film recreates that night in a way that some will find sentimental, but its. Nasty bishop was not historically accurate joyeux noel. The cat who was shot for treason in the first world war. In the north of france, scottish and french troops were in one trench and the enemy german troops were arrayed against them not more than 50 yards awayas was often the case in.
In his podcast about the historical accuracy of films, based on a true story, creator. In 1914, world war i, the bloodiest war ever at that time in human history, was well under way. I know that various specific elements are at least loosely based on reallife events e. The astonishing war story that a nation chose to forget telegraph. The movie joyeux noel tells the inspirational story of the christmas. It is a touching film about an informal truce which took place on the western front on christmas day in 1914. Joyeux noel pinknews staff writer december 7, 2005 war films produced through cooperation between the combatant countries have had a fairly solid track record over the years. There was a spontaneous ceasefire, as the troops on both sides laid down their weapons and observed the birth of the savior in whose name they were killing each other. It was written and directed by christian carion, and screened out of competition at the 2005 cannes film festival the film, which includes one of the last appearances of ian richardson before his death, was. Sony pictures classics released joyeux noel to theaters on november 9, 2005. Just watched joyeux noel and its the first ww1 movie ive seen, im more interested in ww2 and vietnam movies but this was a great movie and was just wondering what other members recommendations would be. During world war i, enemy soldiers up and down the trenches put aside their weapons and chose peace. Joyeux noel is one of the greatest movies ever made, and i like to show it just before introducing a u. Film research analysis of joyeux noel 779 words bartleby.
Joyeux noel merry christmas is a french film released in 2005 that is based on the famous xmas truce of 1914. Of course, if one ever decided to make a film about the war in iraq, one can easily imagine carions footage being salvaged. That film, joyeux noel merry christmas, a panoramic portrait of soldiers from three. Academy award, golden globe and bafta nominee for best foreign film, joyeux noel merry christmas tells the truelife story of the spontaneous christmas eve truce declared by scottish, french and german troops in the trenches of world war i.
Every year, since 1919 on the second sunday of november, the closest sunday to the 11th november armistice day we hold remembrance sunday. Enemies leave their weapons behind for one night as they band together in brotherhood and forget about the brutalities of war. It shows that people fighting in the trenches were not that different from each other. It focuses on the story of several individuals from germany, scotland, france, and their role in the famed christmas armistice during world war one in 1914. Carion decided to cut the trial scene from the film when extras working on the film thought it went overboard. Its setting on the western front, in the first year of world war one is no ones idea of festive, and its true that war and loss dont exactly have the feelgoodfactor we associate with the. Joyeaux noel, or merry christmas, is an international production about the brief christmas armistice between the allies and the germans in world war i in 1914. As a british person, i have grown up with the tradition of remembrance. French film joyeux noel tells the story of the world war i christmas truce from the point of view of french, british, and german soldiers.
A christmas truce forged by germans, french and scots the new. With the christmas season upon us, i wanted to cover a film thatd help represent the christmas spirit. The film merry christmas and the real story of the 1914. Based on the true story of three armies in the bloody trenches of world war i and the miraculous christmas eve truce they unexpectedly forge. Joyeux noel, which translated to english means merry christmas, was. He is accurate, however, in depicting the aftermath. In the midst of the horror of world war i, history records a rare moment of conciliation. Rentals include 30 days to start watching this video and 48. The films historical accuracy is an issue of much debate and there have definitely been. Communication studies, the conservatory of music and dance and umkc libraries sponsored a showing of the 2005 french film joyeux noel for their event the christmas truce of 1914. All of theseas well as the sainsburys adare quite moving, and from a historical perspective get many details of the early part of the war correct. Joyeux noel merry christmas is a 2005 epic war drama film based on the christmas truce of december 1914, depicted through the eyes of french, scottish, and german soldiers. At the end of the closing credits it states, the story is based on a. So, some years back, i remember watching an absolutely wonderful film called joyeux noel, which is apparently based on actual events during world war i namely, the christmas truce of 1914.
In 2005, french filmmaker christian carion released his second fulllength feature film. How historically accurate is the film joyeux noel answers. The irony of this gesture is made clear in the opening scenes of joyeux noel, in which schoolchildren. Nicholas comeau joyeux noel is a french film which was released in germany in 2004 and then across the world in 2005. It takes full advantage of its dramatisation to keep viewers invested in the more personal conflicts and dilemmas, so that by the time characters reach their end points, viewers cannot but want a better and more. The truly remarkable thing about this story is that, despite how hokey it may sound to some, its all pretty much entirely true. Throughout the film, we follow the german, french, and scottish soldiers as they learn to set aside their differences, put themselves in each others shoes, and manage to have a cease fire on christmas. The film also features a foraging ginger cat adopted as a mascot by both the french and the germans. At the end of joyeux noel, theres a bit of text on the screen that says the characters are fictional. Joyeux noel, a new film, directed by christian carion, is about the unofficial 1914 christmas truce in. And in the opening months of that first great war, a most extraordinary and most. A short cross curricular project with history based on the christmas truce of 1914 with 3 tasks for pupils to choose from after theyve watched the film. To get in the holiday spirit, rob looks at joyeux noel set on christmas eve 1914 during wwi when all the french, scottish, and german soldiers.
524 1358 680 585 167 55 655 707 1418 867 38 6 588 348 436 782 899 247 1186 338 829 836 961 1379 939 502 962 614 266 1084 459 727 1275 1260 905 1010 99 265 707 311 1232 1131 983 730 564 1200 1332 237